McCaleb Metzler, A Bankers Insurance Company

McCaleb Metzler, A Bankers Insurance Company

4253 Lankford Highway
Exmore, Virginia, 23350

Phone: 757-442-6187

Fax: 757-442-4149


  • Business Details


McCaleb-Metzler is an independent insurance agency, offering all lines of coverage.  Established in 1947, we know the insurance marketplace and can navigate it for you.  We listen to you, recommend options, and provide quotes for your business, home, auto, or boat.  We strive to ensure you receive the right coverage at fair and competitive pricing.  Our reputation is built upon being the insurance experts, strong on service.  Let us be your trusted agent.


Business Insurance

Every business is different.  Insurance coverage needs to be tailored for each client.  We identify your risks and provide custom solutions for any sized business.  No matter how unique or complex, let us earn your trust.


  • Property
  • Business Auto
  • General Liability
  • Umbrella Liability
  • Workers Compensation
  • Business Income
  • Flood
  • Boat - Protection and Indemnity, Crew, Jones Act
  • Group Life and Health
  • Errors and Omissions
  • Directors & Officers
  • Professional Liability
  • Employee Dishonesty
  • Transportation
  • Cargo
  • Bonds

Personal Insurance

Ever add up how much you pay in insurance each year?  An average person pays for homeowners, auto, health, life, and more.  Let McCaleb-Metzler ensure you have the best coverage at the best price.  Let us be your full service agent.  


  • Home
  • Auto
  • Flood
  • Boat
  • Life
  • Health
  • Disability
  • Personal Umbrella




Chincoteague Chamber

Search Businesses

Chincoteague Visitor's Guide

Office Hours:
Mon.-Sat. 9AM - 4:30PM

6733 Maddox Blvd.
Chincoteague Island, VA 23336

Main Office: (757) 336-6161

Click here for directions

Tide Chart Virginia Tourism You'll Love Our Nature